There's a horse I see every winter. Fifth over two and a half miles on heavy and beaten a long way. The paper says it didn't stay. Next time it drops back in trip on soft again and gets beaten just as far. The trip got the blame. The trip was never the whole story.
Distance and ground sit in two different boxes on the racecard, so most punters treat them separately. They work together, though. A mile and a half on good ground is often a steady pace and a sprint for home. On heavy ground it's a different test altogether, a long grind where the winner is whatever's still going.
Researchers in New Zealand put some numbers on this earlier this year. They timed how horses finished flat races over different trips and going, and found the two work together. On very heavy ground the usual quicker finish could disappear completely, so the last part of the race was run slower than everything before it. It's another country and it doesn't prove anything about betting, but it fits what you see on a wet February afternoon.
So before I forgive a horse for fading, I write down what the race was really asking of it. Was it the trip? The ground? Both together? Then I look at today. Back to a trip it has won over on similar ground is a genuine change. Back in trip but onto deeper ground might just be the same question asked a different way.
It works for good form too. A horse that has won three on good ground hasn't shown you a thing about soft. If today is soft, that lovely form came from a different race.
None of this sits in my rules as a sectional time or a number. It's simply how I read a line, and it's one of the reasons a horse with a poor last run can still be a BSP Favourite while a horse with three wins in a row gets left out. Every horse on the members' card has been read this way before it gets there.
Lee
PS: this is chapter 3 of my free guide How to pick the right favourites. There's a race in there to practise on.
Get Lee's next selections
The horses, the stakes and the reasons, every racing morning.
- By email
- On Telegram
- On the members' website
More from the notebook: Mojito Des Mottes, and the best month in the book · The results pick the method, not me